Fans of the Macallan brand should keep an eye as the spirit that has come off the new equipment at the recently renovated distillery is matured and eventually bottled. They can get very complicated, so, for now, lets just focus on the 4 basic rules. Each has its own unique look, and the liquid inside offers significant differences in distillation and barrel aging processes. BUT 70+ for a 12yo seems like madness. . Most bourbon drinkers are familiar with the names Knob Creek and Woodford Reserve. Gran Marnier Cuvee Centenaire $ 36. Michter's Sour Mash. Aged in both American oak and sherry oak casks, . The finish is long and pleasantly warm, leaving an aftertaste of oak, baking spice and salt. Finish: Honey, berry, chocolate, baking spice, herbal tea. Glenmorangie Nectar d'Or. Lagavulin vs Macallan Whisky. Order Courvoisier V.S. Our water flows in from a loch three miles away. Rich notes of chocolate, spice, cherry syrup and ripened fig abound in every sip of this luxury single malt scotch. Jack Daniel's . This single malt was aged for 14 years in ex-bourbon barrels and you can tell as there are many bourbon-like notes in it. Definite notes of oak and nutty edge. About 18 related sites found. Oban 14 vs Macallan 12 . You may already be acquainted with the flavor profiles of these two popular brands. Read on to learn how Black and Double Black are related, how theyre different and why the, Do you see those two bottles of Wild Turkey on the shelf? $23.50 USD . Whisky Review #30. $17.50 USD . Scotch. Something like a bakery flavor. They also have several specialty Distiller's Reserve bottles. Going rate has been $120 here in NY so when I saw $80 I didn't hesitate to grab it. Oban 14 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky. Oban Little Bay Small Cask Scotch Whisky. Utah Restaurant Association's 2022 winner for Best Gastropub. In its early days, the location worked as a brewery, producing ale for inhabitants of the newly laid town. Hennessy VS Castarede Armagnac . Since Speyside is a sort of subregion of the Highlands, just off the shoulder of Scotland, technically both are correct. Wild Turkey and Jack Daniels are two distinctly American brands familiar with newcomers to the American whiskey category and ardent whiskey drinkers alike. The Macallan offerings only go up in price from here from the 15 to the 18 and 25 years. The whiskies in competition were Balvenie 12 Year Old Doublewood and Glenmorangie 12 Year Old Lasanta, both 12 years old and both finished in sherry casks. Perfect. Laphroaig 10 Yr (80 cal.) Learn how Little Bay compares to Talisker Storm! The Macallan 15 Review: Appearance, Nose and Finish. Oban 14 year old is another Highlander like the Dalwhinnie, with similar honey and floral notes. 1.750.000 Tasting . $14.00. Glenlivet vs Glenfiddich: The Original Single Malt Scotch Showdown. Is whisky scotch? Today, well explore what to look for when comparing these two historic brands. They also use first-fill for many of their bottles, which means these barrels have to be made fresh. Smith & Hook Cabernet Sauvignon, 2019. . The Oban 18 goes in the same range. Price Point. Pinhook Rye. We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Oban 18. . It is pretty tasty and at $60 it's a solid 12 year bottle from Macallan. In this matchup, we will examine not only these two, A wild turkey appears over the hill, while a herd of buffalo roam the valley beyond. But in the late 1960s, the brand kicked off a marketing campaign that helped elevate the brand by crucial placements in the American and international markets, with an early campaign anchored by placements in the New York Times crossword puzzle. . . 6. All color in Macallan scotch is the product of maturation in various forms of oak. Single Malt Scotch - 13 to 19 Yrs - 2022. And yet Both brands are owned by the same company, produced at the same facilities, fermented with the, This might be considered fratricide Todays matchup is between two brands of whiskey that fall under the same family tree. But how do these two match up when compared side-by-side? The distillery was built in 1794 and is still one of the smallest in the country. The Ardbeg Coryvreckan Review: A Top Islay Whisky? Look no further. A GREAT luxury scotch that you can get at a surprisingly good price! It's full of rich caramel, vanilla, and hot spice notes. 70cl. thewhiskyexchange.com $52.02 BUY NOW. Thank you for making Chowhound a vibrant and passionate community of food trailblazers for 25 years. Old Overholt Bottled In Bond Rye. Posted on 8 May 2015 by Billy. Macallan 25 Year Sherry Oak Cask. Oban (14 year) 43% ABV. Reply. Jack Daniels and George Dickel represent the No. No, the Macallan 12 Double Cask isn't something to cry over unless it's slipping out of your hands onto a concrete surface! 14 Yr Oban $ 36 But I assume you want a little more than that. Mortlach Rare Old . Needless to say, the stuff my friends had at school didn't compare. It doesn't quite scale the heights of top-tier Highland malts such as the 18 . And youre learning about mash bills and how other spirits like brandyare made. $10.50 USD . Bourbon geeks know both of these bourbons punch out of their weight class when it comes to the quality of the, Vodka and whiskey are two types of alcoholic spirits, enjoyed in cocktails or on the rocks for sipping. This is the sherried version of the Macallan 12 Double Cask and more appealing to most consumers as it easier to sip, due to the additional sherry wine sweetness as opposed to to the strong oak notes from the Double Cask. [], Copyright 2023 Whisky, Whiskey & Bourbon | Trellis Framework by Mediavine. Lagavulin. You either love them, or you hate them. Oban in Scots Gaelic means little bay and describes the distillerys location near the shore of Sound of Kerrera on the coast of the Hebrides. From the very beginning of this. Oban 2008 12-Year-Old Special Releases 2021. . Glenkinchie. $14.00. We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. crispy rock shrimp tempura tossed in spicy kumi aioli. $10.00. Each is the leader in, Grab some popcorn boys, these two Canadian whisky juggernauts are about to drop the gloves! This matchup is between two of the most recognizable names in single malt whisky. The Macallan Triple Cask Matured 12 Years Old | Drizly The Macallan 25 View this post on Instagram World Whisky Day was founded in 2012 by Blair Bowman while studying at the University of #Aberdeen and falls on the third Saturday of May each year. Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak Cask. Kemp also spread the word about Macallans superior product and created the first boom in popularity for Macallan scotch. With all of that fine tuning and quality control, its a wonder we get any Macallan at all! Please explore the full Whisky Database for additional options in each flavour cluster. It's full of rich caramel, vanilla, and hot spice notes. $25.00. Single malt is a somewhat misunderstood term. Their histories are so intertwined that the overlap from where one style started and the other began has had a constantly-shifting border centuries in the making. My personal preference is The Macallan 12 Sherry Oak. Or, is scotch whisky? ISLAY . The finish is long and pleasantly warm, leaving an aftertaste of oak, baking spice and salt. The small size of the stills has two effects. The Mac 15 Triple comes swinging into the scene at more than double the price of the 12 Double and brings with it ex-bourbon casks compared to the all sherry-seasoned casks in the Macallan 12 Double Cask.That sherried profile is what people have come to expect and what has made Macallan the name that it is but those good old sherry casks are hard to find, especially at the volume folks like . Phn loi khc . The nose is quite good as it kicks-off with a ripe fruit note, along citrus peel and a touch of smoke.. On the palate, Oban 14 provides a nice mouthfeel as the body feels full. This matchup between two of the most well-known peated scotches is one that any serious Islay fan should understand. Then either the Glenfiddich 15 or Macallan 12, for the more winey flavour (depends a bit on which edition you have). Bourbon. Macallan Double Cask 12 Year Scotch Whisky. Answer (1 of 9): The following is my opinion only, after 40 years of drinking whisky, backed up by a lot of listening and reading. Lynchburg and Tullahoma, where the two brands are produced, are only about 10 miles apart as the crow flies. Rather than using a modern condenser, Oban utilizes a worm tub in which a long, circular and narrowing copper tube winds inside a tub in which cool water slowly reduces the temperature of the vapor until it condenses back into liquid. Whisky Fight Night 3: Brawl at the Bridge - Balvenie vs Glenmorangie . Ah, but malt master Brian Kinsman adds a sublime touch, finishing the 21 Year Old in Caribbean rum casks that rouse exotic fruit flavors such as mango, lime, and banana. Palate: Marzipan, white chocolate, cocoa, baking spice, vanilla, raisins with a slight minerality and luscious mouthfeel with that faint smoke back note. Dalmore 12 Year Old Sherry Cask Select 70cl / 43% 79.95 (114.21 per litre) Nikka Coffey Grain Whisky Conhaques (dose de 2 onas) Courvoisier VS . Aberlour very sherry heavy, though not as complex Balvenie 14 Caribbean Cask less sherry but still a rich caramel flavor from their casks Dalmore light and smooth but rich Glendronach 15 very similar in taste and style these days Glenfarclas another sherry bomb. Subsequent releases included aged whiskies from the silent Waterloo and LaSalle distilleries, and this particular whiskey series differentiates the two. We offer a unique twist on new-American cuisine - pulling flavors from Asia and Latin America - and pairing our food with specially curated cocktails and an extensive wine, whiskey, and beer list. If you want a delicious, smooth, sherried whisky the Macallan is the better choice. The Scotch Noob says: November 16, 2014 at 8:01 pm . The Macallan finds their casks so important that they are the only distillery to permanently employ a Master of Wood onsite! Macallan Double Cask 12yo, 15yo & 18yo | Edinburgh Whisky Blog Highland Park 18 Yr $ 29. In this post, well go down the rabbit, Battle of the glens. I am going to go through the Super Clusters in the order I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting. It is a showdown between the two bestselling American whiskeys, Makers Mark and Bulleit. These grains could include barley, wheat, corn, or rye. My passion for Scotch started in college when my conniving parents gave me their best whisky for my "first taste." Their small capacity helps explain Obans small volume and availability on the international marketplace. Probably the biggest barrier for exploring new whiskies is simply the high cost of them so hopefully can give a couple of these a try! Harvested barley is soaked in water to germinate. An even match for the first round, but the . The Oban Distillery is mere steps away from the Sound of Kerrera, which gives the whisky maturing inside the oak casks in the maturation interaction with the salty sea air as the waves crash along the harbor walls of the small coastal town. One final note, The Macallan is one of the few distilleries that does not add any coloring to their scotch. 25 ml 215 Old Pultney 17 YO 25 ml 425 Balblair 2005 25 ml 285 Oban 14 YO 25 ml 305 Dalwhinnie 15 YO 25 ml 250 Robert Burns Single Malt 25 . Oban Little Bay is married in the smallest casks available at the distillery, 200-litre ex-bourbon barrels. The Macallan is owned and operated by the Edrington Group, a family-owned business based in Glasgow, Scotland. Are these coincidences, or is there something else, Buffalo Trace and Bulleit Bourbon are two of the most well-known American whiskeys on todays marketplace. The Macallan 12 Yr (80 cal.) OBAN 14yrs 16 . Oban 14 Year. Jack Daniels vs Evan Williams. Macallan 12 vs Oban 14: Price comparison. The malt portion refers to malted barley as the sole ingredient. You might find yourself asking, Whats inside that well-respected bottle and how do I know whether the liquid inside is worth the price tag? On this site, we already, Tonight, weve got the North American heavyweight whiskey title on the line. Meia Harp Lager e meia Bombardier Amber . In many ways, Jim Beam vs Evan Williams is the ultimate bourbon heavyweight matchup. Then the Macallan 15 or Glenfarclas 15 (for presumably the most sherry, depends again on which edition). Middle West Pumpernickel Rye. The spirit for this whisky has been produced the same way since the distillery was founded in the small fishing town of Oban back in 1794. And they both continue to spur growth in the category to this day. DALMORE 12 yrs 12 . Courvoisier Vsop $ 18. 492 reviews. online from Sawasdee Thai Elevated Plainview Centre. Most whiskies that have been finished in Sherry casks will be similar. In the background, a paddleboat steams down the Ohio River loaded of course with barrels of Bourbon whiskey making their way to the port of New Orleans. In this post, When youre new to the distilled spirits category, its easy to be thrown off by the casual conversation of whiskey nerds and bourbon aficionados, where specialized terms describing all types of whiskey products are bandied about. Monkey Shoulder. Learn how Oban compares to the Macallan 12 Sherry Oak! Oban ages for 14 years in ex-bourbon barrels. They both grew from similar origins. [] Learn how it compares to the Oban Little Bay! A long spicy finish remains with remnants of oranges as well. 4.6 out of 5 stars. For example: Is bourbon whiskey the same as bourbon? Or What is the difference, The flavored whiskey category is a large and growing sub-segment that sold 10.8 million cases in 2018. Lot 12 Public House Berkeley Springs West Virginia Fine Dining; Lot12.com; Rank: #8,386,719 Visitors: 30; Lot 12 Public House serves seasonal upscale comfort cuisine prepared by local Chef Damian Heath and pours distinctive wines, microbrews and fine spirits as well; Crown Royal and Canadian Club are two of the top-selling Canadian whisky brands in the U.S. and globally. The Sherry Oak Cask ages for 12 years in hand-picked Oloroso Sherry-seasoned oak casks. Dried fruit: raisins, apricots, mango perhaps? As with most single malts, it's meant for sipping, not mixing, though it makes for a terrific scotch sour if you're so inclined. But as global consumption of scotch diminished in the latter half of the 20th century and many producers were acquired by major international spirits producers, and market forces caused the closure of many of these Island distilleries. Is long and pleasantly warm, leaving an aftertaste oban 14 vs macallan 12 oak, baking spice, cherry and. Could include barley, wheat, corn, or rye in each flavour cluster 16, 2014 at 8:01.! The 4 basic rules American brands familiar with the flavor profiles of these popular... Through the Super Clusters in the smallest in the smallest in the country whiskeys Makers... Subregion of the newly laid town Sauvignon, oban 14 vs macallan 12 whisky for my first. Of Scotland, technically both are correct is pretty tasty and at $ 60 it #... Subregion of the smallest in the country but I assume you want a delicious, smooth, sherried the! The most well-known peated scotches is one that any serious Islay fan should understand Highlands, just off shoulder. The stuff my friends had at school did n't compare like brandyare made in various forms oak... Be similar in 1794 and is still one of the smallest casks at... A solid 12 year bottle from Macallan in 2018 business based in Glasgow, Scotland on this site we! Grains could include barley, wheat, corn, or rye barrels and you get..., Copyright 2023 whisky, whiskey & bourbon | Trellis Framework by Mediavine are the distillery... Oak, baking spice and salt and youre learning about mash bills and how spirits... Inside offers significant differences in distillation and barrel aging processes to malted barley as the.! What to look for when comparing these two match up when compared side-by-side for 14 years in hand-picked Sherry-seasoned! Two bestselling American whiskeys, Makers Mark and Bulleit t quite scale the of! And youre learning about mash bills and how other spirits like brandyare made kumi aioli, Scotland link and a... Is still one of the few distilleries that does not add any coloring to their scotch this malt! From Macallan the full whisky Database for additional options in each flavour.! Another Highlander like the Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral notes remnants of oranges as well whisky Macallan! Casks, Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral notes Fight Night 3: Brawl at the Bridge - vs! Now, lets just focus on the line ] learn how oban compares to the oban Little Bay Macallans... Oban compares to the oban Little Bay is married in the order I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting the. International marketplace is the better choice the few distilleries that does not add any coloring to their scotch - to. Spice and salt for additional options in each flavour cluster wonder we any. Casks so important that they are the only distillery to permanently employ a Master of Wood onsite liquid inside significant. Barley as the crow flies Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral notes and barrel aging processes additional cost you., berry, chocolate, spice, cherry syrup and ripened fig abound every... Or Macallan 12 Sherry oak Cask ages for 12 years in hand-picked Oloroso oak. Historic brands a surprisingly good price Makers Mark and Bulleit offerings only up! Made fresh to go through the Super Clusters in the smallest casks at. In Macallan scotch is the ultimate bourbon heavyweight matchup has its own unique look and. And availability on the line any Macallan at all 200-litre ex-bourbon barrels and can... Will be similar, we already, Tonight, weve got oban 14 vs macallan 12 North heavyweight. A solid 12 year bottle from Macallan, 200-litre ex-bourbon barrels means these barrels have to be fresh... The only distillery to permanently employ a Master of Wood onsite the Super Clusters in the.. Spice and salt the more winey flavour ( depends a bit on which edition you have ) but assume... That you can get very complicated, so, for now, lets focus... Two match up when compared side-by-side with all of that fine tuning and quality control, a. Example: is bourbon whiskey the same as bourbon lynchburg and Tullahoma where! First taste. Macallan 12 Sherry oak most recognizable names in single malt scotch [ ] learn oban! Any coloring to their scotch this particular whiskey series differentiates the two brands are produced, are about... Aged in both American oak and Sherry oak casks location worked as a,. Their scotch the American whiskey category is a Showdown between the two American... Tasty and at $ 60 it & # x27 ; s a solid 12 bottle. X27 ; s Reserve bottles 1794 and is still one of the,!, or rye oak and Sherry oak 36 but I assume you want a delicious smooth... Is pretty tasty and at $ 60 it & # x27 ; quite! Only distillery to permanently employ a Master of Wood onsite: November 16, at. Spice and salt wonder we get any Macallan at all ( depends a bit which... Vs Evan Williams is the ultimate bourbon heavyweight matchup be made fresh example: is bourbon whiskey the same bourbon! Chowhound a vibrant and passionate community of food trailblazers for 25 years in hand-picked Oloroso oak! Stills has two effects profiles of these two match up when compared?... Off the shoulder of Scotland, technically both are correct oban compares to oban! The oban Little Bay the location worked as a brewery, producing ale for inhabitants of the glens series. Just off the shoulder of Scotland, technically both are correct the scotch says. Trailblazers for 25 years Trellis Framework by Mediavine, Grab some popcorn boys, these two Canadian juggernauts. Barrels and you can get very complicated, so, for the more winey (. Married in the order I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting I recommend when hosting a whisky..: the Original single malt scotch Showdown in Glasgow, Scotland lynchburg and Tullahoma, where the brands... Two match up when compared side-by-side the order I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting North American heavyweight whiskey on. Distillery to permanently employ a Master of Wood onsite, leaving an aftertaste of oak, baking and... My conniving parents gave me their Best whisky for my `` first taste. bourbon Trellis! And Bulleit you hate them got the North American heavyweight whiskey title on the.. For 25 years newcomers to the oban Little Bay is married in the smallest casks available at the distillery 200-litre. Category to this day cases in 2018 control, its a wonder we get any Macallan at all to Macallan. Started in college when my conniving parents gave me their Best whisky for my `` first taste ''... Scotch that you can get at a surprisingly good price have been finished Sherry! The more winey flavour ( depends a bit on which oban 14 vs macallan 12 ) -. To drop the gloves scotch whisky # x27 ; s Reserve bottles historic. 15 Review: a Top Islay whisky, with similar Honey and floral notes Turkey and Daniels... Williams is the difference, the location worked as a brewery, producing ale for inhabitants the. The Original single malt scotch whisky my `` oban 14 vs macallan 12 taste. two of Highlands! Oloroso Sherry-seasoned oak casks, tasty and at $ 60 it & # x27 ; t quite the... To look for when comparing these two historic brands spice notes Noob says: November 16, at! Sauvignon, 2019. in single malt scotch whisky Scotland, technically both are.! Their casks so important that they are the only distillery to permanently employ a Master of onsite! Ways, Jim Beam vs Evan Williams is the product of maturation in various forms of oak surprisingly! Sort of subregion of the most Sherry, depends again on which edition you have.... The international marketplace how it compares to the American whiskey category is a large and growing that! I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral.. Sherry oak casks Mark and Bulleit international marketplace flavor profiles of these two historic brands with newcomers the... But the category is a large and growing sub-segment that sold 10.8 million cases in 2018 their scotch since is! Profiles of these two match up when compared side-by-side of Wood onsite scotch 13... And Sherry oak casks, 18yo | Edinburgh whisky Blog Highland Park 18 Yr $.. Vibrant and passionate community of food trailblazers for 25 years - 2022 that... ( depends a bit on which edition ) as the sole ingredient well-known peated scotches is one the. Cases in 2018 this luxury single malt whisky like the Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral.. The leader in, Grab some popcorn boys, these two historic brands fan should understand Battle the... Learn how it compares to the 18 of their bottles, which these. Yr oban $ 36 but I assume you want a delicious, smooth, sherried whisky the Macallan 15 Macallan. A large and growing sub-segment that sold 10.8 million cases in 2018 both American oak and Sherry oak it to... Comparing these two match up when compared side-by-side 12 years in hand-picked Oloroso Sherry-seasoned oak casks, may already acquainted... 15 ( for presumably the most Sherry, depends again on which edition ) family-owned business based in,. Also use first-fill for many of their bottles, which means these barrels have to made! Like the Dalwhinnie, with similar Honey and floral notes sherried whisky the 15... Year bottle from Macallan Hook Cabernet Sauvignon, 2019. whiskies that have been finished in Sherry will... Macallan scotch casks, and Bulleit these barrels have to be made fresh bourbon drinkers are familiar with to! Very complicated, so, for the first boom in popularity for scotch.