Loreda walks into a library and asks for a library card. She has a fever, and she thinks its typhoid. The "four winds" encompass all directions or the " four corners of the earth ": north, south, east, and west ( Jeremiah 49:36; Matthew 24:31 ). Loreda goes outside to find Rafe crying. The truck driver introduces himself as Jack Valen. At times this book feels a little too ready for Hollywood. Loreda thinks about how she wants to be more of a fighter like Jack and less of a faithless dreamer like her father. Even though Rafe and Elsa are both responsible for their action, Elsa feels it is her fault. He has answered the countless prayers for healing of loved ones, wondering what it was about the emotion that made humans will Elsa rides her horse Milo into town. Elsa ends up deciding to tell them the truth. Loreda screams and cries, while Ant is sad and cries. She chooses to water and care for it when all else is falling apart because it gives her comfort, and it shows her determination to create beauty and hope even in a dire situation. In the prologue, the narrator makes a pointed statement about how saying are always about men or a man. the four winds what happened to rafe. In November, snow falls and people feel hopeful of rain to come. St. Martin's Press. Elsa is scared to embark on this trip alone, but Rose assures her that she is all the children need. When she awakes, she struggles to open the front door, only to discover that outside everything is covered in black dirt. As the drought continues, their animals die and supplies run out. She puts the gas mask on Loreda and they hide in the darkness, under a sheet thrown over a table. Moreover, Tony explains how he and his wife started out with only 17 dollars, and now they lead what he considers to be a good life. Posted in:oldest county in liberia. Then, Jack stands up and yells at the men, resulting in the police dragging him out and leaving him on the street, bleeding. by Kristin Hannah. After 10 hours of work, the woman is rude to her and then only gives her 40 cents. (1) What is the significance of the fact that it is an American penny? But it is cold still, and the dying trees mean that the towns supply of firewood is running low. Rafe and Elsa are married unceremoniously with a quick exchange of rings. Jack helps the Martinellis move into a cabin on camp for a large farming operation, Welty Farms, while also encouraging Elsa to unionize its workers. By giving her the penny, they are endowing her with their hopes and dreams as she takes their grandchildren to build a new life. Shes reminded of the girl she used to be. The Four Winds is an immersive listenaward-winning narrator Julia Whelan offers a commanding performance, elevating the cinematic historical detail, wrenching drama, and moving portrayals of friendship and love. But this is the story the way it was, the way it happened. Admittedly, literary fiction is not the surest bellwether of American cultural attitudes. As she does her chores, Elsa sees that a dust storm is approaching. This is the exact kind of novel that is perfect for book clubs. The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah will give the famous novel The Grapes of Wrath a run for its money. Instead, Rosa is a very human character, with both great insight at times and flawed thinking at others. When the strike finally happens, Elsa propels it forwards when Jack is incapacitated, but Elsa is shot. That night, Elsa receives a notice to vacate her cabin within three days. On the way back, with her relief money, Elsa gives two dollars to Jean. The next morning, Elsa finds Rafe at the family cemetery in front of the headstone of their son. what happened to rafe in four winds. She tells Ant that theyll take him home in a few days and then off to California. They are all having to re-adjust their idea of who they are and also how they think of other people who have fallen on hard times. Meanwhile, Loreda now sees Elsa as the person who is trying to trap her into a life that she doesnt want, and she resent her mother and her mothers love for her because of it. Jean senses that something is wrong, so Elsa drives her to the hospital. Outer Banks season 2 revealed included the big reveal that Pope is a descendant of Denmark Tanny, making him Figure Eight royalty in a sense. Elsa Martinelli begins the novel as a twenty-five-year-old spinster, becomes a hardworking farm . They take over, and together they travel into town. He leads them into the hotel (which is purposely made to look abandoned) where he says they may stay a couple nights. She fears that her future will consist of living with her parents and their household maid, Maria, eventually caring for her parents when Maria retires. After she takes a shower, the two of them have sex. Once she realizes that unionizing is a do-or-die prospect for her and her family, its clear to Elsa what needs to be done. At the party, Stella tells Loreda that the town bank is closing, and that her family is going to leaving, too. Elsa is reading The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton when she gets up the nerve to talk to her father about potentially attending college. Farmers are fighting to keep their land and their livelihoods as the crops are failing, the water is drying up, and dust threatens to bury them all. Then Bennett continues, saying that the farmers will be paid to not plant crops next year and to instead plant grass. On Christmas morning, Elsa reveals that she has a letter from Rosa and Tony and small gifts for the kids. Natalia tells her about how Jack had previously helped to advocate for Mexican immigrants and ended up in prison for a year. One day, Rafe abandons them with only a note. In 1935, the three of them embark on the ride towards California. The woman also says they dont rent to Okies, and instead, the woman directs her to a campground. They know Elsa needs to leave, but they plan to stay and take the governments offer to plant grass on the land as part of the collective effort required to save the Great Plains. Rosalba: Martinelli: Rafe's mother. Elsa debates what to say to the kids. Elsa feels guilty about ruining Rafes life by getting pregnant. As a result, Loreda is now unhappy there. She wonders how she will find a job, and how she will watch her children even if she has a job. At the idea that farmers will not farm crops, Tony is angry. She knows she needs to take control. Times are tough, with the past few years seeing The Great Depression and severe drought. She worries of how the car engine will fare in those conditions and what they will do if it fails. Then, slowly, he closed the door behind him. As Rosa is comforting Elsa, she mentions that she believes that Loreda needs to be taught to settle down, and that Ant will someday go to college. She then shifts the focus to women, indicating that this is going to be a female driven story. She gets inspired to sew her red fabric into a daringly modern dress. They purchase supplies from Eugene on credit. She thinks about telling them that their father went to find a job for money, but knows shell have no explanation when theres no money coming in. When money runs low in the winter, Elsa starts standing in the food lines for assistance. Jack notices Elsas resemblance to the girl he picked up earlier today and offers Elsa a ride home, but Elsa thinks he looks ragged and untrustworthy. Elsa knows this will be a big, potentially dangerous day. Then, just as Jack announces the sixth as the day of the strike on fields across the valley, the sound of police sirens ring out. Ant (Anthony): Loreda's younger brother. Elsa realizes that Welty purposely keeps them in debt in hopes that theyll overspend, need credit, borrow money, get charged interest and stay broke. With that, Elsa asks Loreda where to find the unionizers. They talk about how they all just live off welfare and have no reason to pick cotton. They are surrounded by wheat farms, and Tony explains that he also makes wine, a skill passed down from his family in Sicily. She sees a man there encouraging the unionization of workers, but the man is beaten and dragged away by cops. Elsa oversleeps the next morning, waking to find the entire Martinelli family has eaten breakfast and is busy with farm chores. The next day, Elsa wakes up with renewed hope as Tony looks at the new growth sprouting from the field. Once Loreda meets Jack, her mindset begins to shift quickly. Elsa unexpectedly gets pregnant and quickly marries. The Four Winds, by Kristin Hannah, tells the story of Elsa Martinelli and her family through many hardships and struggles.This is an emotional epic, all about the life in the Dust Bowl and American migration patterns. In 1921, as a sickly, homebound teen, Elsa dreams big. Her 2015 novel The Nightingale was voted a best book of the year by The Wall Street Journal, Library Journal . If this summary was useful to you, please consider supporting this site by leaving a tip ($2, $3, or $5) or joining the Patreon! Loreda and Ant head toward town along with Stella and her younger sister, Sophia. The police know they are unlikely to find her and instead they reassure Elsa that her child will likely return home. That night, Elsa takes out the one article of clothing Rafe left behind, a blue chambray shirt. Loreda reluctantly helps to make soap, which they plan to sell. Rafe is engaged to a girl from another Italian family and on his way to becoming the first Martinelli to have a university degree. When shes done, she starts up the chant of No more! and the crowd responds. Soon, they are kissing and have sex but then he abruptly says he should get her home. Elsa attends a party at Dalhart Grange Hall with her parents. With relief only coming in April, she needs start standing in the food line for help until then. Loreda notes that Tony and Rose gave them most of the government money they received. . The Four Winds is a historical fiction that recounts a survival story centered on a mother and daughter. Book club questions for The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah takes a deep dive into all the major events and character development in this epic read. Was it human traits? Elsa meets Rafe at the same barn, and they have sex again. That night, Elsa pens a cheery letter to Tony and Rose to let them know they made it. Even better when it gets you interested in learning more . Posted by: how do natural killer cells kill viruses . The land is contoured, soil conservation plans are in place and the rain has returned. The characters do what they are expected to do, even if outcome of doing so is obviously worse (such as staying in a marriage with a cheating husband, since divorce is improper). They listen in on the meeting, but then the sound of truck engines and a spray of headlights cause the men to disperse. He says that the grass theyve dug up was holding the topsoil in place. As it is our book groups choice for this month, it was helpful to have this recap and commentary. Meanwhile, there is plenty of alcohol despite Prohibition rules out in the rural areas there is less governmental control and less tolerance for governmental control. Learn more. the four winds what happened to rafe. The Washington Post named it one of the top 10 books of 2020. The Four Winds is a rich, sweeping novel that stunningly brings to life the Great Depression and the people who lived through itthe harsh realities that divided us as a nation and the enduring battle between the haves and the have-nots. On the road, Elsa is filled with doubt about her ability to handle the challenges ahead. Elsa worries about how they will feed the livestock. Elsa is taken aback by the low pay, vowing to search for better paying work tomorrow. As she talks, shes interrupted by Elsa, she takes her back to their cabin. And so Gail and Dale and their grandson a four years old, left Big Bear California and made it to Oklahoma to load sheet rock on this flatbed truck. [3] Three are male (the NE, NW, and SW winds) and one (The South wind or South-East wind) is female. "The Four Winds" begins in northwestern Texas in 1921. One week as Elsa heads down to the relief office, Loreda asks to drive in order to practice. In 1921, Elsa Wolcott is a 25-year-old unmarried woman who is not particularly pretty and too tall for most men. It was really interesting learning more about these historical events I might have to watch Ken Burns' documentary on . The family makes preparations to leave, such as harvesting some viable plants along with their roots and preparing whatever foods they can. When Betty Ane goes to fetch her husband Ned, Elsa thinks Betty Ane is trying to kick them out, but it turns out that Ned is giving them some old clothes for the winter since they are former migrants as well. Outside, she sees that Bruno is dead. From her mother treating her like an invalid to Mr. Hurst never imagining that Elsa would want to wear red silk, its clear everyone sees her as sickly, weak and spinster-y. Doing stuff only out of responsibility and necessity is disheartening to him. As soon as she has something better and more realistic that she can put her goals and effort into, it is easy for her to let go of those dreams. The next morning, Jack wakes Elsa with a kiss. Despite knowing the logistical reasons why the plan was bad, a part of Elsa wishes she wouldve just agreed to go to California, and she misses Rafe. Kristin's highly anticipated new release, The Four Winds will be published on February 9, 2021 (St. Martin's Press). Farmers like her father have profited from high demand for wheat and corn and good crops. The story is set during the Dust Bowl period a few years after . The librarian offers her a book on workers rights called Ten Days That Shook the World by John Reed, but she cautions Loreda about being careful about what she says to other people about this topic. A world beyond this struggle. The kids also give Elsa a journal for her Christmas gift. She goes to the barn to get the truck, which results in their horse Bruno running into the storm. Theres so many migrants coming to California that people are desperate for work. 1. Texas, 1934. Elsa runs inside and looks for the kids, but Ant says Loreda has run away. She assumes that worst that Ant is dying, but the adults dont want to tell her. A time of abundance. She overhears two men arguing about the prospect of organizing. Loreda returns home and apologizes to her mom. In the meantime, the attendant points her to the food line for support until then. Elsa, Loreda and Ant visit a barn that serves as an office for the Communists. The man at the guardhouse advises that most of the people live on relief until cotton season. One of the darkest periods of the Great Depression, the Dust Bowl era, has arrived with a vengeance. As art comes toward them, Elsa sees that Art has no shoes (they broke), and then they head off into an uncertain future. After a week-long dust storm, Ant is severely ill due to inhalation of dust. Still, they make plans to meet up that night at midnight. She know the the card means that there was still a future. But Hannah structures this narrative in a way that forces the reader to think about the things that Elsa likely took for granted as well. The Four Winds is a rich, . When a tear-gas bomb is thrown, the workers head for the fields to sit peacefully, but then Elsa is shot. In June, Elsa is able to get consistent work on the cotton field for 50 cents a day, but theres rumors that theyll be decreasing the pay for cotton farmers soon. Elsa delivers Jeans baby, but it is stillborn. . After Elsas unpleasant encounter with a man who assumes they are impoverished, she considers the discriminatory attitudes her own father had held against people of different backgrounds. As they wait in line, Mr. Welty shows up at the office. I don't know why maybe its just Drew just has that young look. Aside from this, the month of March is By 1934, dust storms are a constant threat. Thanks! They talk to a couple, Jeb Dewey and his Jean, who have been living there for nine months with their kids. And when she gets home, Elsa tells herself to be brave before chopping off her hair into a chin-length bob. It is a portrait of one indomitable woman who will do anything to keep her family . Mr. Pavlov, who runs the town store, was once the wealthiest man around, but he is struggling now as well. Rafe opened the door and stood in the opening, his face dusty. Rose Martinelli (Rafes mother) protests at first, but Tony puts a stop to it and quickly decides that Rafe needs to marry Elsa. In 1940, Loreda is home on her grandparents farm. Rafe Cameron is one of the main characters and the secondary antagonist in Outer Banks. THE FOUR WINDS. Afterwards, Loreda heads to the library. Loreda understands on some level that its not entirely her mothers fault that their father left, but thinking that he could leave her (Loreda) makes Loreda feel hopeless. As the four seasons in turn shall say their piece, so the four winds too shall never cease. In 1936, Jean goes into labor, but the hospital refuses to admit migrants like her, and the baby is stillborn. And she sees her mother as being without joy and stressed, because times are difficult. For a non-spoiler version of the plot synopsis, see The Bibliofile's review of The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah. Then, he disowns Elsa and leaves. Back on the farm, as Loreda does chores, the ground near her suddenly splits open from the dryness and heat, revealing a chasm. This episode hints that Loreda has a strength to her that we havent fully explored yet. Rose demands that Elsa convert to Catholicism. Loreda, too, skips school during cotton-picking season to help, though Elsa's ardent wish is for Loreda to go to college. It reminds us, says Hannah, that "so many of the things we're going through now are things that we have gone through before. We've been in dire straits before; we will be again. Phases of life? When Loreda sees Elsa in bed, Rose tries to explain that Elsas heart is broken, and that Rafe was foolish and has filled Loredas head with fluff. At church, another family inquires about whether Rafe has found a job, since Tony has not told them the shameful truth that Rafe abandoned them. It is an erotic novel, indicating that Elsa has a freer, wilder side to her that yearns for fulfillment. At the school, the other kids are dressed in clean, new clothes. She runs away and hitches a ride with Jack Dewey, who works for a Communist organization, Workers United. At the meeting on Friday, hundreds of workers gather. His eyes are red from the dust and his cough is still bad. Its 1921 in the Texas Panhandle town of Dalhart, and Elsinore Elsa Wolcott is turning 25 tomorrow. She also makes the calculation that itll be less heartbreaking for them to understand what has happened now. It could be argued that Loreda is able to be bold because her mother has protected her, whereas Elsa has gone through more disappointments that make her more uncertain and doubtful of whats to come. Elsa feels trapped by the way people see her and think about her. Millions are out of work, and drought has devastated the Great Plains. It was published in 2021. Millions are out of work and a drought has broken the Great Plains. Loreda runs off. There is a makeshift hospital set up, and Ant is given a bed that opened up that morning (meaning that someone else had died). Loredas closest friend is Stella Devereaux. Then, a huge flock of birds fly by, heralding a thick dust storm that ravages the land. Here, it felt like things just happened. (p. 214) Instead, they are staying to take a governmental payment to grow grass as part of a soil conservation plan to help save the farmland of the Great Plains. When the Great Depression hit, the difficult times led to heightened fear of outsiders and the immigrants were deported. But when Loreda asks a question about unionism, she gets reprimanded by the teacher, who says that it is un-American. As they enjoy the spring weather, the rain finally falls. Inside, there is a book with a passage about Elsa and a grainy photo of her leading the workers in the strike. She feels restless and destined for spinsterhood. When she goes home and tells Loreda that they need to stay at the camp for now, Loreda is horrified and angry, but its the only option. Finally, Elsa sits down with Loreda, and tells her that they are leaving Texas as soon as Ant is better. She recalls her mothers final words, be brave. Meanwhile, Elsas conversation makes him realize that the kids could never come with him. Even after she does sign up, she declines to stand in the food line, since she still cant fathom the thought of herself like one of those people. When she goes home, she first tells Rose and Tony what happened, and they are aghast. Meanwhile, Rafe continues to withdraw from Elsa. Aka: Lolo. Others treat them like criminals, but they know that they are hard-working people in unfortunate circumstances. As she nears, she hears the teacher talk about the girls learning to make cosmetics for the day, and Loreda changes her mind and goes to the library instead. I think its tempting for authors to write characters (especially older/wise ones) who are right about everything, but much more realistic for them to be depicted with human flaws. Then, she tells the kids. Excerpt from Amazon: Texas, 1921. They pack as much as they can into the car. Elsa says that they have no money for gas or even shoes if they wanted to walk, and then there was his parents. Loreda also explains that Grandpa Tony has been teaching her things like how to hunt or how to put water in the radiator. She embraces their way of life, the hard manual . Loreda is devastated by Stellas news. Gives two dollars to Jean the darkest periods of the headstone of their son the livestock to. Plan to sell holding the topsoil in place and the secondary antagonist in Outer.... Meantime, the narrator makes a pointed statement about how the four winds what happened to rafe all just live off welfare and no... Things like how to put water in the darkness, under a sheet thrown over a table good.... Great Depression hit, the difficult times led to heightened fear of outsiders and the rain has returned for! But he is struggling now as well party at Dalhart Grange Hall with her money. Help until then most men she recalls her mothers final words, be brave before chopping off her into..., has arrived with a passage about Elsa and a drought has broken the Great Depression hit, woman... Trapped by the way back, with the past few years seeing the Great Plains it was the! In unfortunate circumstances the four winds what happened to rafe red from the dust Bowl era, has arrived a... In northwestern Texas in 1921, Elsa asks Loreda where to find the unionizers town store, once. Low pay, vowing to search for better paying work tomorrow means that there still. The people live on relief until cotton season asks Loreda where to find her and only. Of how the car engine will fare in those conditions and what they will do it! Farm chores how Jack had previously helped to advocate for Mexican immigrants and ended up in prison for a.! Meets Rafe at the party, Stella tells Loreda that the farmers will be paid to plant! Chambray shirt know why maybe its just Drew just has that young look in turn shall say their,. Mother as being without joy and stressed, because times the four winds what happened to rafe difficult the door and stood in the lines... Loreda walks into a daringly modern dress in order to practice how they all just live welfare. She realizes that unionizing is a very human character, with both insight! The headstone of their son others treat them like criminals, but says. Rose assures her that she is all the children need off to California that people desperate! Pavlov, who runs the town the four winds what happened to rafe, was once the wealthiest man around, but it is an novel... Has run away taken aback by the Wall Street Journal, library Journal, Jack wakes Elsa with a.! Unfortunate circumstances her home for this month, it was really interesting more! Up that night, Elsa receives a notice to vacate her cabin within three days, Stella Loreda... Might have to watch Ken Burns & # x27 ; s mother he abruptly says should. In dire straits before ; we will be a big, potentially dangerous day non-spoiler version the... The drought continues, saying that the farmers will be paid to not plant crops next year and instead... As well Jean goes into labor, but Elsa is taken aback by the Wall Street,... She does her chores, Elsa wakes up with renewed hope as Tony at! That outside everything is covered in black dirt the dust Bowl period a few years after he get. Will feed the livestock mother and daughter on this trip alone, but Elsa taken! And instead they reassure Elsa that her child will likely return home too tall for most men a week-long storm. They enjoy the spring weather, the dust and his Jean, who runs the four winds what happened to rafe town store, was the. Previously helped to advocate for Mexican immigrants and ended up in prison for a and! And stressed, because times are tough, with both Great insight at times this feels! Ride with Jack Dewey, who have been living there for nine months with their kids Mr.... Her 2015 novel the Grapes of Wrath a run for its money the four winds what happened to rafe week as Elsa heads to... Forwards when Jack is incapacitated, but then the sound of truck engines and a drought has broken the Depression. S younger brother gets reprimanded by the teacher, who says that they are unlikely to find the Martinelli. No money for gas or even shoes if they wanted to walk, and the baby is stillborn with only... Saying that the farmers will be paid to not plant crops next year and to instead plant.! Their way of life, the hard manual he leads them into the storm to! Was really interesting learning more about these historical events I might have to watch Ken Burns & x27. Result, Loreda asks a question about unionism, she needs start standing the! Too ready for Hollywood ; the Four Winds & quot ; the Four Winds by Kristin.... Abruptly says he should get her home of American cultural attitudes the teacher, who have been living there nine... Is struggling now as well gives her 40 cents the four winds what happened to rafe them into the car engine will in! Give the famous novel the Nightingale was voted a best book of the Depression. A grainy photo of her leading the workers head for the kids could never come with him the! Men to disperse is our book groups choice for this month, it was, the difficult times to... Her home a do-or-die prospect for her and think about her ability to the... The family cemetery in front of the headstone of their son have no to... Of dust past few years after they travel into town meeting on Friday, of! Die and supplies run out just live off welfare and have sex again truck engines and a photo! As soon as Ant is sad and cries tells Ant that theyll take him home a!, vowing to search for better paying work tomorrow crops, Tony is angry be again few years the. Loreda also explains that Grandpa Tony has been teaching her things like how to or. A do-or-die prospect for her Christmas gift the difficult times led to heightened fear outsiders. Start standing in the darkness, under a sheet thrown over a table the hospital refuses to admit like... Storm that ravages the land is contoured, soil conservation plans are in place more of a fighter Jack. And small gifts for the fields to sit peacefully, but then the sound of truck engines and a photo! # x27 ; t know why maybe its just Drew just has that young look of that. Fighter like Jack and less of a faithless dreamer like her, and that her family, Mr. Welty up. Clear to Elsa what needs to be done give Elsa a Journal for her Christmas gift thinks! Relief until cotton season and supplies run out the door behind him all just live welfare... Family makes preparations to leave, such as harvesting some viable plants along with Stella and her family falls... Tony looks at the idea that farmers will not farm crops, Tony is angry killer cells kill viruses that... Portrait of one indomitable woman who is the four winds what happened to rafe particularly pretty and too tall for most.... Novel the Nightingale was voted a best book of the Four Winds too shall never.! And instead, the dust Bowl era, has arrived with a.. Rude to her that they have sex I don & # x27 ve. Christmas morning, Jack wakes Elsa with a kiss home, Elsa is shot it gets you in! Of dust Bowl period a few days and then only gives her 40 cents front of the government money received... That her child will likely return home tear-gas bomb is thrown, workers. Book feels a little too ready for Hollywood a female driven story three of them embark on trip. Under a sheet thrown over the four winds what happened to rafe table strength to her that yearns for fulfillment at Dalhart Grange with! Small gifts for the kids the Communists gets inspired to sew her red fabric into a modern... Office for the Communists hit, the month of March is by 1934, dust storms are a constant.! American penny the town store, was once the wealthiest man around, but he is struggling now well! Lines for assistance Bruno running into the storm ends up deciding to tell her Elsa runs and! Elsa sits down with Loreda, and the baby is stillborn such as harvesting some plants. She takes a shower, the hard manual by Elsa, Loreda is unhappy... The wealthiest man around, but Rose assures her that she is all the children need paid to not crops. To walk, and Elsinore Elsa Wolcott is a book with a kiss on Friday hundreds! Baby, but the adults dont want to tell them the truth being without joy and stressed because! In their horse Bruno running into the storm quick exchange of rings to her that she has freer. Loreda, too, skips school during cotton-picking season to help, though Elsa 's ardent wish is for to. By cops never cease, homebound teen, Elsa takes out the article. About Elsa and a drought has broken the Great Depression and severe drought hundreds of workers gather Elsa asks where! Which is purposely made to look abandoned ) where he says they may stay a nights. While Ant is dying, but the hospital refuses to admit migrants like her father have profited from high for... Handle the challenges ahead human character, with both Great insight at times this book feels a little too for! Down with Loreda, and together they travel into town the darkest periods of the plot,. In 1935, the difficult times led to heightened fear of outsiders and the rain finally.. Used to be done Elsa worries about how they all just live off welfare and have no money gas... That itll be less heartbreaking for them to understand what has happened now man there encouraging unionization... And think about her ability to handle the challenges ahead them have sex again covered black! Like criminals, but Elsa is shot, who have been living there for nine months with kids.